Adhiban loses for possessing analog watch in National Teams 2020
by Shahid Ahmed - 08/02/2020
Airport Authority of India leads both open and women section at the conclusion of day 2 of 40th National Team Open and 18th National Team Women. The biggest shock of the day came in round 3 of open section when GM Adhiban Baskaran of PSPB had to forfeit the match for possessing an analog watch after 16 moves against IM C R G Krishna of RSPB-B. GM Karthikeyan Murali scored a marathon victory against GM Thejkumar to make sure his team beat RSPB-B. In the women's section, all top seeds scored a victory. Only AAI did a whitewash again, resulting in them jumping into the lead ahead of all other teams. Photo: IA Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Adhiban loses due to rules technicality in Round 3
After playing a fantastic game yesterday, Adhiban took a rest in round 2. In round 3, team PSPB (Petroleum Sports Promotion Board) faced RSPB-B (Railway Sports Promotion Board). Adhiban was paired against IM C R G Krishna. However after 9 moves were made, Adhiban was found to be wearing a wrist watch which according to the tournament rules and regulations meant a loss. In the past there have been several cases in India of players losing a game because of a watch, however, this was the first instance when a grandmaster was affected by it.
C R G Krishna - Adhiban's opponent | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
The first GM casualty in India of the analog watch rule - GM B. Adhiban | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
This is the watch that Adhiban was wearing | Photo: B. Adhiban
Speaking to ChessBase India after the incident, Adhiban said, "I just came back from Gibraltar. At the Gibraltar masters there was no such rule about wearing of a watch and all kinds of watches were allowed. I was completely jetlagged and forgot about the watch rule. My opponent claimed the win and there was nothing I could do about it." Unlike a walkover, a loss due to the watch rule affects your rating and Adhiban lost 7.7 Elo points. At a rating of 2654, that's quite a bit. However, as always Adhiban was positive and said, "I am happy that my team won the match in spite of my loss. I am playing good chess and that is more important to me than rating points."
The main clause in FIDE's Arbiter's manual is 184.108.40.206 under Anti-Cheating Guidelines
It is clear that from the FIDE laws electronic devices are not allowed. How was Adhiban given a loss when he was wearing an analog watch? A few years ago, when the rule 220.127.116.11 was implemented the arbiters all across the country were faced with several instances where they had to decipher an analog watch from an electronic one. Logically if a watch had batteries in it, it would become an electronic one. But it was not always easy to segregate the two. In order to make things less complex and avoid unnecessary appeals, AICF in its Central Council meeting came up with the clause that no watches are allowed. Although this rule was not specifically mentioned in the regulations of the National Team Championships 2020, it was discussed in the player's meeting before the start of the event.
Famous trainer, mentor and chess consultant IM Vishal Sareen tweeted about Adhiban's loss
Here are the 9 moves that were played in the game.
IM Sayantan Das held GM Abhijeet Gupta to a draw | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Karthikeyan Murali got material advantage after the 36th move of the game against Thejkumar M S as he had a Rook for a Bishop and Pawn. However the game went on for another 73 moves before the former secured a much needed victory for himself as well as the team.
Karthikeyan gave his all to score a very important victory | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
IM Arghyadip Das (2458) had a good position until he blundered against GM Lalith Babu (2550).
Lalith - Arghyadip, Round 3
Find out the best continuation for black after 30.Rd8
Arghyadip blundered here with 30...Ne7 and lost the game in another four moves.
Lalith scored two important victories for his team today | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
GM Srinath Narayanan (2535) of Air India scored a decisive victory over IM Vignesh N R (2436) of RSPB-A as all other three games of his team ended up in draws which resulted in Air India winning against RSPB-A by narrow margin 2.5-1.5
Srinath scored the decisive victory for his team | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Reigning National Junior champion Aradhya Garg (2169) of Delhi B played solid and held GM Visakh N R (2518) of AAI to a draw. Rest of the team members of Delhi B lost against AAI, thus the final score 0.5-3.5 went into AAI's favor and shot them into the sole lead.
Aradhya Garg receiving his National under-19 open championship trophy last November | Photo: Jitendra Choudhary
GM Arjun Erigaisi's (2563) woes continued as he was held to a draw by IM Sidhant Mohapatra (2367). In the final moments of the game, Sidhant had some chances which he did not take and allowed Arjun to force a perpetual after initially not going through with the draw. Despite Sidhant's valiant efforts, Telangana defeated his team Odisha A 3-1.
Arjun - Sidhant, Round 3
Find out why 33.Rg2 is a mistake
Kshatriya and Vedant - The Vekhande brothers scored impressive draws each against higher rated players | Photo: Chess Guru
10-year old Kshatriya Nitin Vekhande kept his impressive run as he held reigning National Amateur champion Kartavya Anadkat to a draw.
Rupesh Ranjan shocks Arjun Erigaisi in Round 2
Round 2 also witnessed the top seeds scoring a victory for their team. However only Air India and RSPB-B managed to score 4-0 against Bihar A and Madhya Pradesh respectively. The biggest upset of the round was caused by Rupesh Ranjan (1889) of Bihar B defeating GM Arjun Erigaisi (2563) of Telangana.
Rupesh Ranjan beat Arjun Erigaisi in a topsy-turvy game | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Erigaisi had a complete decisive advantage for quite sometime until he blundered which Rupesh capitalized upon.
Rupesh - Erigaisi, Round 2
Find out the best continuation after 26.Qxh4
Black continued with 26...Qb5, white went ahead 27.f5 Bxf5 which was a blunder.
Find out why 27...Bxf5 is a blunder
Rupesh's teammates Himanshu Ranjan and Kumar Gaurav lost to GM Harsha Bharathakoti and IM Rahul Srivatshav P respectively. Sudhanshu Ranjan (1978) held IM PDS Girinath (2353) to a draw.
Team LIC's spearheads Sriram Jha and D K Sharma scored a draw each | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Although the top seed PSPB defeated LIC 3-1, GM Sriram Jha (2383) did not make things easy for GM Karthikeyan Murali (2602).
Sriram - Karthikeyan, Round 2
What should white do after 22...Bd4 ?
White managed to gain another pawn with 23.Nxc5 but that was not enough as the game reached into a double rook and opposite color bishop endgame, where practically it was not possible for white to convert two extra pawns advantage into a full point.
Former National Blitz champion IM D K Sharma (2293) gave it all against GM Deep Sengupta (2534) but Deep's gritty defence did not allow Sharma to gain more than a half point.
GM Abhijeet Gupta and GM Lalith Babu of PSPB scored wins with ease against Brajesh Agarwal and Gajendra Singh of Team LIC respectively.
Sriram Jha and D K Sharma - the dominant duo of team LIC | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Senthil Kumaran R P (1957) of Tamil Nadu A held GM Swapnil Dhopade of RSPB-A to a draw. Despite being passive for the majority of the middlegame, Senthil managed to not make any huge mistake and salvage a draw. Senthil was the only person to score for his team as they went down by 0.5-3.5 against the strong RSPB-A.
The young team AAI defeated Gujarat D by 3.5-0.5, however Jay Kundaliya (2071) held former World Junior Silver medalist GM Abhimanyu Puranik (2597) to a comfortable draw.
Team AAI is full of youth and fresh talent | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Jay Kundaliya was the only one of his team to score a draw | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
RSPB-A defeated Gujarat B by 4-0 comfortably | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Hemal Thanki (2154) of Gujarat D missed a golden opportunity against Harshavardhan G B (2377).
Harshavardhan - Hemal, Round 2
Find out the winning continuation after 22.Ng3
Black continued with 22...e3 and lost the game in the next ten moves. It is safe to assume that time trouble could be a primary reason behind black missing out the quicker and simpler win with 22...Bd4. This win wouldn't have changed the overall team score, but a win is a win.
Team Air India whitewashed Bihar A 4-0 | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Team RSPB-B scored another whitewash 4-0 this time over Madhya Pradesh | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Sarayu Velpula beats WIM Rakshitta Ravi in Round 2
Reigning National under-13 girls and National School under-14 girls champion Sarayu Velpula (1867) defeated WIM Rakshitta Ravi (2214). Mary Ann Gomes, Padmini Rout and Nisha Mohota all scored a victory each, making sure PSPB scored a 3-1 victory over Telangana.
PSPB Women's team beat Telangana 3-1 | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Air India defeated Tamil Nadu A emphatically by 3.5-0.5, however Kannamma P Bala (2095) held IM Tania Sachdev (2397) to a draw.
Bala Kannamma held Tania Sachdev to a draw | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
Reigning National under-11 girls champion Anupam Sreekumar (1745) held WIM P Michelle Catherina (2175) to a draw. That wasn't enough for the team as Kerala went down against Tamil Nadu B 0.5-3.5
Anupam held WIM Michelle Catherina to a draw | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran
AAI thrashed the unrated Himachal Pradesh B 4-0
Team AAI scored two 4-0 whitewash | Photo: Gopakumar Sudhakaran