The many ways of seeing

I have always wondered how a chess player’s style is determined.

Why does one player become an attacking player while another develops a positional style? Why are some players naturally drawn towards complications while others seem to enjoy quiet manoeuvring?

More importantly, when two grandmasters look at exactly the same position, do they actually see the same thing?

The pieces are arranged identically. The rules are the same. Both players have access to the same information. Yet their understanding of the position, the moves they consider, and the possibilities they find interesting can be remarkably different.

Does personality determine style? Does our early exposure to certain ideas influence what we eventually become good at? Or does the way we perceive positions gradually develop into what we call our style?

These questions became particularly interesting to me after reading a book that had nothing to do with chess.

Eleven Walks, Eleven Different Ways of Seeing

Alexandra Horowitz’s On Looking: Eleven Walks with Expert Eyes explores a deceptively simple idea.

Horowitz takes walks through familiar surroundings with different companions, each bringing a particular expertise or perspective.

A geologist notices details in stones and buildings that others would walk past. A sound expert draws attention to sounds that most people barely register. A child notices things that adults have learned to ignore.

The surroundings remain the same. What changes is the person observing them.

I found this to be a wonderful illustration of perception in chess.

Imagine showing the same position to eleven different grandmasters.

One might see an opportunity to seize the initiative, while another might be more concerned about the opponent’s counterplay. One might immediately begin calculating concrete variations, while another might first consider how the position could evolve.

They may eventually arrive at the same move, but the paths they take to reach that decision could be entirely different.

And perhaps even more interestingly, a possibility that appears obvious to one player might never seriously enter another player’s consideration.

The difference is not necessarily in what they know, but in what they notice first, what they consider important, and what they choose to investigate.

Where Does Style Come From?

In my early research into chess coaching and how players develop their individual styles, I came across an interesting contrast between Grandmasters Peter Leko and Judit Polgar.

One of Leko’s favourite chess books during his formative years was about Tigran Petrosian, a player renowned for his positional understanding, defensive technique, and prophylactic thinking. Polgar, on the other hand, developed a strong interest in tactical chess at a very young age.

Peter Leko vs Alexander Beliavsky

Alexander Motylev vs Judit Polgar

Both went on to become extraordinary players, but their styles were remarkably different.

Peter Leko became known for his solidity, precision, and deep positional understanding. Polgar became famous for her tactical imagination, attacking instincts, and willingness to enter complicated positions.

This made me wonder whether their early interests shaped not only how they played chess, but also how they perceived positions and developed their styles.

Did their preferences shape their abilities, or did their natural abilities lead them towards those preferences? How much does early exposure influence the player they eventually become?

A young player immersed in tactical combinations may develop a greater sensitivity to attacking possibilities, while someone studying Petrosian might become more attentive to prophylaxis and long-term positional factors.

But perhaps their natural aptitudes attracted them to these subjects in the first place.

I suspect style develops through a continuous interaction between what we enjoy, what we study, what we become good at, and what we learn to notice.

Over time, this becomes self-reinforcing, creating a distinctive way of seeing chess.

But could it also create limitations?

The Blind Spots of Expertise

Expertise is usually associated with the ability to see more.

A grandmaster recognizes patterns that a beginner cannot and can often understand the essential characteristics of a position almost immediately.

But expertise also teaches us what to ignore.

There are too many possibilities in chess to examine everything. Strong players learn to eliminate moves quickly, recognize promising candidates, and focus their calculation on what seems relevant.

This filtering process is essential for making good decisions. Yet it raises an interesting question.

What happens when the possibility we dismiss is precisely the one we should investigate?

A player who values pawn structure might overlook dynamic compensation. A tactically oriented player might dismiss a quiet manoeuvre. Someone particularly sensitive to material might fail to appreciate a long-term sacrifice.

Our experience makes us efficient, but it also influences what receives our attention.

This reminds me of a fascinating psychological phenomenon called inattentional blindness, where concentrating on one task can make us miss something unexpected, even when it is directly in front of us.

The following experiment offers a wonderful demonstration. Try watching it before reading further.

The Monkey Business Illusion | Video: Daniel Simons

What makes this experiment interesting is that we do not necessarily miss things because we lack the ability to see them. Sometimes we miss them because our attention is occupied elsewhere.

I wonder how often something similar happens in chess.

We become so accustomed to looking for certain patterns and evaluating positions through familiar principles that other possibilities may never receive serious consideration.

The same experience that makes us stronger can sometimes limit what we see. And perhaps, under certain circumstances, it can make us less original.

Being Different Is Not Enough

This brings me to what I consider an essential condition of originality.

To be original, it is not enough to be different. The difference must also be valuable.

Dick Fosbury offers a fascinating example. At the 1968 Olympics, he surprised the world by clearing the high-jump bar backwards, challenging the conventional techniques of the time.

But what made his approach revolutionary was not simply that it was different. It was effective. Fosbury won Olympic gold, and his technique eventually became the standard in high jumping.

Had his method offered no real advantage, it might have remained little more than an unusual experiment.

Dick Fosbury Changes The High Jump Forever - Fosbury Flop- Mexico 1968 Olympics

The same applies to chess.

Anyone can play an unusual move. In almost every position, there are legal moves that have rarely, if ever, been played. But novelty by itself has little meaning.

A genuinely original move might reveal an overlooked tactical resource, introduce a new strategic concept, challenge an established evaluation, or create practical problems that make the opponent’s task considerably more difficult.

Being different for the sake of being different is relatively easy. Finding a valuable reason to be different is much harder.

There is also the question of recognition.

An original idea may not be appreciated immediately. It may conflict with established principles or appear unattractive to players accustomed to evaluating positions in a particular way. Its value may only become clear after further analysis or practical experience.

But rejection alone is not evidence of originality.

The challenge is to distinguish between an idea that has been dismissed because it is genuinely poor and one that has been dismissed because it falls outside conventional understanding.

That requires both imagination and discipline.

Can We Learn to See Through Someone Else’s Eyes?

Returning to Horowitz’s book, I find the central experiment particularly appealing. The surroundings remain the same, but what each observer notices is different.

Could we deliberately apply this approach to chess?

Consider two fascinating games:

Ding Liren against Magnus Carlsen in 2019

Tigran Petrosian against Wolfgang Unzicker in 1960

In the first, Ding, playing Black, moved his king from g8 to f7, back to e8, and eventually to d7, with queens and several other pieces still on the board.

In the second, Petrosian gradually walked his king from g1 to b1, spending several moves on what might initially appear to be an unusual manoeuvre.

Both players were willing to move their kings in ways that many of us might instinctively reject. Yet the positions demanded very different considerations.

What interests me is not simply that both players made unusual king moves. It is that they were willing to investigate possibilities that another player might dismiss before seriously considering them.

A player looking for immediate activity might struggle to appreciate Petrosian’s patience. Someone accustomed to prioritizing king safety might find Ding’s manoeuvre difficult to contemplate.

Neither approach is universally correct. The position determines whether an idea works. But our experience and preferences influence which ideas we consider in the first place.

This is where I find the idea of looking through someone else’s eyes particularly valuable.

Studying Petrosian should not mean trying to imitate his style. Nor should studying a dynamic player mean searching for complications in every position.

Instead, we might try to understand what made certain possibilities visible to them. What questions were they asking? What were they willing to consider that we might have rejected?

We cannot examine every possibility, and our individual ways of seeing will always remain incomplete.

But perhaps by learning to look through someone else’s eyes, even briefly, we can discover possibilities that our own habits of thinking might never have allowed us to consider.

Learning to Look Again

Anatoly Karpov once famously remarked, “Style? I have no style.”

I find this fascinating because Karpov had one of the most recognizable styles in chess history.

His positional precision, prophylactic understanding, and ability to gradually restrict his opponents were so distinctive that his play was compared to a boa constrictor.

Yet he claimed to have no style.

Perhaps Karpov was not consciously trying to play in a particular way. Perhaps he was simply trying to find the best move in every position.

What appeared to others as a distinctive style might have been, to him, the most natural way of understanding chess.

This brings me back to the question with which I began.

Why do different players see the same position differently?

Our interests influence what we study. What we study shapes what we notice. And what we notice influences the decisions we make. Over time, these decisions form patterns that others recognize as our style.

But however experienced we become, our perception remains incomplete. We cannot see everything, and someone else may notice what we have overlooked.

Perhaps the challenge is not to escape our own way of seeing, but to recognize that it is only one of many possible perspectives.

And perhaps Karpov’s remark contains something more interesting than a denial of style.

He may never have set out to develop a distinctive style. He was simply trying to play the best chess he could. Yet the way he understood the game made his chess unmistakably his own.


This article is taken from Vishnu Prasanna's Substack.